Wednesday, April 10, 2019

Lawrence of Arabia: The Story Behind a Hero of World War I


The 1962 film Lawrence of Arabia, is a film that depicts the experiences of British Colonel T.E. Lawrence in the Arab Uprisings of the first world war. The film itself covers Lawrence’s time as a British Officer in the Arabian Peninsula; and his involvement as leader of the Arab revolt against the Turkish army, and the delegator of the Arab National Council. The film tries to portray Lawrence's heroic/courageous deeds, while also showing the psychological affects that the war would burden on him.

While the film itself is based of the story of T.E. Lawrence, it is better understood to be a depiction of the book Seven Pillars of Wisdom, by T.E. Lawrence. The film, as well as the book, can be seen as more of Lawrence’s personal depiction of the events that happened on the Arabian Peninsula than a true historical record of what took place. Historians debate whether or not the accuracy of all elements of Lawrence’s accounts, saying that he may have embellished aspects of the story to be more favorable towards himself. Besides Lawrence’s possible reconstruction of events, the film makers would also take liberty in making slight changes of the events of the story to better fit how they wanted to represent it. 

 The film also does a decent job of representing the historical subtleties of the story. They did a good job in matching clothing, equipment, etc. to those of the time period. They did however fail to be historically correct with some of the historical gear of the time. One of the most glaring inaccuracies was the weaponry within the film. These include: the Turkish army using an American 1919 browning machine gun (during a battle in 1918), the rebels only using British SMLE Enfield rifles (even before being resupplied by the British), and T.E. Lawrence using a British Webley revolver (when in fact he carried an American Colt 1911 handgun). While these inaccuracies are minor in the overall scheme of the film, they do take away from the immersion for those who know/catch these mistakes.

 The film does an overall good job at capturing the essence of the story Lawrence of Arabia. While being produced in the 1960s, the film has aged very well. While some select scenes in the film struggle due to the technology of the time, most of the it is very well filmed. It is a truly amazing how well they were able to achieve the visuals they were without more modern technology.


Work Cited


Anderson, Scott. “The True Story of Lawrence of Arabia.” Smithsonian.com, Smithsonian Institution, 1 July 2014, www.smithsonianmag.com/history/true-story-lawrence-arabia-180951857/.

Dud, Mrs. “Lawrence of Arabia: Hollywood Fact or Fiction?” Dr Dud's Dicta, 30 July 2015, drdudsdicta.com/2014/08/09/lawrence-of-arabia-hollywood-fact-or-fiction/.

Hoffman, George. “T. E. Lawrence (Lawrence of Arabia) and the M1911 » Sight M1911.” Sight M1911 RSS, sightm1911.com/lib/history/telawrence.htm.

Stejskal, James. “The Arab Revolt and the Guns of Lawrence of Arabia.” American Rifleman, 23 Nov. 2018, www.americanrifleman.org/articles/2018/11/23/the-arab-revolt-and-the-guns-of-lawrence-of-arabia/.

Woolf, Christopher. “Is Peter O'Toole's Lawrence of Arabia Fact or Fiction?” Public Radio International, 16 Dec. 2013, www.pri.org/stories/2013-12-16/peter-otooles-lawrence-arabia-fact-or-fiction.

The Treaty of Versailles





The Treaty of Versailles was written in January of 1919 in Paris, influenced by seventy delegates from twenty-seven nations who met to work out a peace treaty that laid out the terms of the postwar settlement with Germany. Although there were representatives from twenty-seven different nations, the treaty was said to mainly be influenced by the big three; the United States, Great Britain, and France.

U.S. president Woodrow Wilson brought ideals from his previous peace proposal, the Fourteen Points, along with the idea of a League of Nations, and the principles of national self-determination each for different purposes. Wilson believed the Fourteen Points, which called for open diplomacy, a reduction in armaments, and freedom of commerce and trade would be successful in bringing unselfish peace among the nations instead of providing punishment for Germany. Insisting on a League of Nations to protect member states from aggression and prevent future wars was important to Wilson for setting a peace standard, although it ended up being to weak to achieve its grand purpose. Wilson's final idea of a national self-determination notion was to allow the people to freely choose their own government through the process of democratic vote. The majority rule would determine the winner of the election. Self-determination also stated they could live free from external involvement in states defined by borders.

Although these were all seen as peaceful resolutions France wanted revenge, economic and financial retribution, and long lasting security from Germany. This took up many discussions between the big three with the main issue being that France wanted a buffer state between them and Germany. This would entail permanent demilitarization of Germany. After being deadlocked with little to no hope of moving forward France finally agreed to compromise and give up the idea of a buffer state in return for French military rule of the region for the next fifteen years along with a defense pact with the United States and Great Britain.

In conclusion, Wilson was the main voice behind the peace initiative, many of his ideas were put down by the majority. One of the most controversial clauses of the treaty that Wilson opposed of was the war guilt clause. The war guilt clause declared that Germany was responsible for the war and had to pay their due reward equal to all civilian damages caused by the fight. The Treaty ultimately stated new German boundaries and assigned liability for reparations. Some claim that this treaty, due to the direct harshness toward Germany, led to WWII. Thoughts?

Citations:

Pruitt, Sarah. “How the Treaty of Versailles and German Guilt Led to World War II.” History.com, A&E Television Networks, 29 June 2018, www.history.com/news/treaty-of-versailles-world-war-ii-german-guilt-effects.
https://www.history.com/news/treaty-of-versailles-world-war-ii-german-guilt-effects

"Fourteen Points" History.com, A&E Television Networks, 16 Nov. 2009, www.history.com/this-day-in-history/wilson-delivers-fourteen-points-speech.
https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/wilson-delivers-fourteen-points-speech